
Titre | Collective quantification and the homogeneity constraint |
Publication Type | Article dans des actes |
Année de la conférence | 2014 |
Authors | Dobrovie-Sorin, Carmen |
Nom de la conférence | Semantics and Linguistic Theory |
Volume | 24 |
Pagination | p. 453–472 |
ISBN | 2163-5951 |
Abstract | The main theoretical claim of the paper is that a slightly revised version of the analysis of mass quantifiers proposed in Roeper 1983, Lønning 1987 and Higginbotham 1994 extends to collective quantifiers: such quantifiers denote relations between sums of entities (type e), rather than relations between sets of sums (type ). Against this background I will explain a puzzle observed by Dowty (1986) for all and generalized to all quantifiers by Winter 2002: plural quantification is not allowed with all the predicates that are traditionally classified as ”collective”. The Homogeneity Constraint – as well as the weaker requirement of divisiveness - will be shown to be too strong (for both collective and mass quantifiers). What is required is that the nominalization of the nuclear-scope predicate denotes a maximal sum (rather than a group). Divisiveness is a sufficient, but not a necessary condition for this to happen. Non-divisive predicates such as form a circle, which denote sets of ‘extensional’ groups are allowed, because extensional groups are equivalent to the maximal sum of their members. It is only intensional group predicates that block collective Qs.Keywords: collective quantification, mass quantification, homogeneous, cumulative, divisive, groups, sums, maximality operator, plural logic |
URL | http://journals.linguisticsociety.org/proceedings/index.php/SALT/article/view/24.453 |
DOI | 10.3765/salt.v24i0.2428 |
Laboratoire de Linguistique Formelle – UMR 7110 CNRS et Université Paris Cité – RNSR : 200112497J
Adresse géographique : Bât. Olympe de Gouges, 5ème étage. 8, Rue Albert Einstein 75013 Paris
Envoyer un courrier : Case Postale 7031 – 5, rue Thomas Mann – F-75205 Paris Cedex 13
Transports : Métro ligne 14 : arrêt "Bibliothèque François Mitterrand" – Tram T3A : arrêt "Avenue de France" – Bus n°89 et 62 : arrêt "Porte de France"
Téléphone : (+33) (0)1 57 27 57 64 – Télécopie : (+33) (0)1 57 27 57 81
Directeur de la publication : Heather Burnett – Dernière mise à jour : 2025-04-30